The reviews for The Shore Club offer a mixed perspective. Several reviewers describe their wedding experiences as magical and flawless, specifically praising the staff's supportiveness and professionalism, the venue's beauty, and the effective management of arrangements, even during last-minute changes. Notably, staff members like Chelsea receive multiple mentions for their exceptional service, and the venue itself is lauded for its affordability and sentimental value. On the other hand, some reviewers express significant dissatisfaction, highlighting issues such as outdated and poorly maintained rooms, a lack of available staff to address problems promptly, and disorganization during event setups which impacted guest experiences and even resulted in damage to personal property. Overall, while many have had positive experiences, particularly with weddings, a few have encountered serious issues, suggesting that the quality of service and facilities may be inconsistent.